How to Carve the Best Pumpkin Ever

This Old House Magazine
At Home

This Old Monster House Pumpkin
This Old Monster House Pumpkin

Here are the expert carvers' tips for every step of the pumpkin-carving process. Follow their advice to create a potentially award-winning pumpkin, and enter our annual Pumpkin-Carving Contest for your chance to win prizes and be featured on This Old House website. -Tabitha Sukhai, This Old House online

See More: Inspirational Pro Pumpkin Carvings

1. Select It
Want to go traditional and carve a gourd straight from the patch? Or would you like your creation to last forever by carving a synthetic pumpkin? Whichever one you choose, make sure you consider your design or pattern when selecting a gourd. Get one large enough and in a shape that will accommodate the length and width of whatever design you're going to carve into it. And before you leave the pumpkin patch, Ryan Wickstrand of recommends the following: "Make sure it can stand well on its own, and never carry a pumpkin by its stem."

If you dread seeing your hard work turn to mush-even with good care, a carved pumpkin will last only a couple of weeks (see "Preservation," below)-consider an artificial pumpkin, such as those available from Funkins. They have precut holes in the bottom to accommodate a flameless light source, the pumpkin walls have already been "shaved" down to a thickness of 1/2-inch (ideal for carving).

See More: Editors' Picks: Best Pumpkin Carvings Ever

2. Carve It
The key to safe carving? Sharp tools. With properly sharpened carving saws and knives, you won't have to use as much force while carving, which reduces the chances of accidental slips that can result in injury. When carving artificial pumpkins, don a mask and goggles to protect yourself from carving dust.

"Nothing slurps out messy pumpkin guts like a good, strong wet/dry Shop-Vac," says Scott Cummins of (image 1). But if yours is out of reach, he recommends scraping out pumpkin guts with a margarine container lid or an empty tuna can. Wickstrand is a fan of the Pumpkin Gutter (not affiliated with Cummins's site), a special drill bit that grips pumpkin gunk and quickly shaves down the inner pumpkin wall.

For increased stability, carve out the smallest pieces first, then work your way up to the larger cutouts. "In fact, it's wise to leave the cut shapes wedged in place until you are finished cutting all the lines. This will provide added support until you're done carving," says Wickstrand. Once all the cuts have been made, pop out the sections with your finger.

Some pros carve freestyle. But using a template to lay out your design on your pumpkin prior to carving can help ensure the look of your jack-o'-lantern. For a This Old House-style pumpkin, you can download our templates:
• Download the exclusive TOH pattern: Scary Second Empire

• Download the exclusive TOH pattern: Creepy Queen Anne

See More: 2011 Pumpkin-Carving Contest Winners

3. Light It
You can create an opening at the bottom of the pumpkin to accommodate a light source. But if you opt for a lid, make sure you cut out a notch for hassle-free replacement. Angle your cuts inward to prevent the lid from falling in.

The light source you choose can affect the life span of your pumpkin. "Using a low-watt electric light instead of candles will reduce shriveling," says Gene Granata of Masterpiece Pumpkins. Try the Pumpkin Powered Light or Ultimate Strobe Light from Pumpkin Masters.

See More: Dremels and Other Pumpkin-Carving Tools

4. Preserve It
Thoroughly gutting and cleaning the pumpkin before you start will make for a longer-lasting carving. But after you carve, Ryan Wickstrand of Zombie Pumpkins suggests sealing in moisture on cut edges by applying a coat of white glue. JP of Jammin' Pumpkins recommends applying petroleum jelly to carved edges to prevent moisture loss. "I like to spray Lysol on the whole carving and inside the whole pumpkin to keep the pumpkin-killing bacteria away," says Stoney of Stoneykins.

Masterpiece Pumpkins' Gene Granata recommends Pumpkin Dunk'n (about $5), a preservative soak that promises to add as much as two weeks to the life of your carving. Meanwhile, 3D carver Scott Cummins of Pumpkin Gutter recommends bagging and cooling your work. "After your pumpkin has been displayed for a few hours and you notice some drying, you can temporarily revive it by completely submerging it in chilled water for a couple of hours. I put a tiny bit of bleach in the water," he says.

Shown above: One of Cummins' creations spends the day bagged and iced, and comes back out again for nighttime display.

See More: 39 Best Pumpkin Carvings of Famous Faces

5. Photograph It

The best way to preserve your pumpkin is to take a good picture of it. But photographing lighted objects can be tricky. Eric Wilhelm, CEO of, who photographs his own jack-o'-lanterns every year, says there are three keys to the perfect capture:

• A steady camera
• Longer than usual exposure times (he photographs his carvings using 0.8 to 2.5 seconds of exposure time)
• No flash.

A tripod is best for keeping the camera steady, because even slight movement can blur your image. If you're just going to rest the camera on a table or other surface, Wilhelm advises using the delayed shutter function (or timer) to give the camera a chance to stop shaking after you hit the button.

Wilhelm also recommends eliminating any background light and placing minimal light sources in front of the pumpkin. "I photograph in a dark room with two side-mounted, low-wattage flood lights pointing toward reflective surfaces," Gene Granata of Masterpiece Pumpkins adds. This gives the pumpkin a presence in the photo.

Shown above: A perfect pumpkin picture by JP of Jammin' Pumpkins that shows a blur-free, lighted carving.

Now Get Carving!
Now that you've got the secrets to creating an award-winning pumpkin carving, go ahead and get started on your masterpiece. And, don't forget to enter The TOH Pumpkin-Carving Contest. Winners will be announced on the TOH homepage on Halloween.

More Pumpkin Carving Ideas on

How to Make a Skull Light

12 Inspirational Pumpkin Carvings
How to Create Beautiful Pumpkin Luminaries