Pine-Sol triumphs as best all-purpose cleaner in Consumer Reports test

Nadine Bells
Shine On
September 28, 2012

Looking for an all-purpose cleaner that lives up to its claims?

Consumer Reports tested 19 all-purpose cleaners against tough kitchen stains, soap scum and mineral deposits. The only product to live up to its claims and clean effectively without streaking? The affordable standby, Pine-Sol.

"In our tough tests, only Pine-Sol Original cleaned well enough to be recommended, earning high marks on all stains," the magazine reports.

"Pine-Sol's only drawback is that it pours rather than sprays. But with convenience comes less cleaning power. Although several sprays excelled at one or two tasks in our all-purpose cleaner tests, they stopped short of being all-purpose," Consumer Reports concludes.

The American magazine found some "green" cleaners to stand out as fairly effective sprays — specifically those from Green Works and Seventh Generation — but warns that not all green claims are meaningful.

[See also: Surprising facts about laundry soaps]

The non-meaningful terms included "natural," "earth-friendly," "ecological," and "nontoxic." No standards exist for these terms, so look for more specific claims.

"USDA Organic," "Leaping Bunny," and "EPA's Design for the Environment (DfE)," on the other hand, are all terms that are verified and regulated.

See the list of meaningful terms here.

The test didn't only involve commercial all-purpose cleaning products. One tried-and-true "home brew" did quite well: vinegar and water.

"We tested a few home brews, including one made with equal parts water and white vinegar. Its overall score topped every commercial spray, especially when it came to streak-free results. But it left behind a strong vinegar smell and fared poorly in our surface-staining test," testers report.

What products do you use to tackle tough stains and soap scum?

More from Shine on Yahoo! Canada

Clean your house in 30 minutes
Surprising uses for baking soda

Most bizarre hotels in the world

What to Read Next

All-Inclusive Northern Europe Luxury Cruises

History, culture and art combine with the absolute comfort of an all-inclusive luxury cruise to create the journey of a lifetime.

You have to check this out!

Great way to meet 45+ singles

Voyage to The Great Wall of China

This winter, explore the grandeur of the Great Wall of China on board the elegant ships of Oceania Cruises.

Gerber LIfe Grow-Up Plan

Insurance coverage for your child? It is affordable and simple to set up! Just click here to find out more from Gerber Life!

Affordable Homes on up to 1-Acre in Culpeper

New single-family homes on ½- to 1-acre homesites, just 2 miles from historic downtown Culpeper and 3 miles from Route 29. From the upper $200s

Need A Dumpster? Use Bagster, A Dumpster In A Bag.

No delivery windows or rental fees - The Bagster bag is ready when you are. Keeps you on a schedule and on a budget.