Buster Posey thinks Phillies reliever Hector Neris plunked him on purpose

Buster Posey has a very high opinion of himself these days.

The catcher for the San Francisco Giants, and pretty much the best position player on the team, got plunked by Philadelphia Phillies closer Hector Neris on Sunday, and he was convinced that it happened on purpose.


Let’s back up before anyone goes after Neris with torches and pitchforks. The plunking happened in the bottom of the eighth inning of Sunday’s game, and the Phillies had two outs and a two-run lead. Neris had just come in, and had to deal with runners on first and second. It had been a close game — the Phillies were down 2-1 until the top of the eighth when they broke out for three runs. Still, it was just a two-run lead, and with two runners on, it wasn’t a time to take anything for granted.

[Now’s the time to sign up for Fantasy Football! Join for free]

Posey was the first batter that Neris faced. And with his first pitch of the entire game, Neris hit Posey on the back. In the video you can see that Neris reacts instantly, and in a way that says “Oh crap, that’s not what I wanted to do!” Posey, on the other hand, immediately starts to look at Neris and even says some words in his direction. There’s no doubt in Posey’s mind that it was on purpose.

Buster Posey reacts after getting hit by a Hector Neris pitch. (Getty Images)

Here’s the thing: Neris hitting Posey on purpose makes absolutely no sense. Not only was it his first pitch of the game, putting Posey on loaded the bases. The Giants had an even better chance of tying the game, so why do that intentionally? Posey’s an excellent hitter (he’s got a .321/.410/.477 line on the season), but it seems really unlikely that Neris would have purposely loaded the bases and put the game on the line just to avoid pitching to him. (He’s good, but he’s not Barry Bonds.) And after the game, Neris said as much.



Intentional plunkings are no joke. They’re dangerous and unnecessary. But pitchers aren’t perfect and mistakes happen. Sometimes a pitch just gets away. There doesn’t have to be any meaning behind it. And even if there was some kind of meaning, it’s pretty unlikely that Neris was scared of Posey.

But maybe Posey was just trying to make himself feel better. The Giants lost the game 5-2, and it was a pretty significant loss.


The Phillies, the worst team in baseball, had officially eliminated the Giants from the National League West race. The Giants aren’t far behind the Phillies, but still: that has to sting.

More MLB coverage from Yahoo Sports:

– – – – – –

Liz Roscher is a writer for Big League Stew on Yahoo Sports. Have a tip? Email her at lizroscher@yahoo.com or follow her on twitter! Follow @lizroscher