Everyone Will Want to Steal These Genius White Elephant Gifts
- 1/48
Everyone Will Want to Steal These Genius White Elephant Gifts
Some would say that a White Elephant exchange runs counter to the holiday spirit. “Stealing presents?!” *Gasp* Our response? Those are the rules—and when approached with the right mixture of levity and mischievousness, the best White Elephant gifts can be a rip-roaring good time. There’s a time and place for stocking gifts for mom and gifts for tweens under the tree—but this is not that occasion.
Perfect for playing with friends and family members, the gist is basically this: Everyone brings something, people choose a gift according to an agreed upon order—numerical, age, whatever—and then you either steal something that’s already been opened or brave the mystery beneath the remaining wrapped presents. One thing to note, this game will definitely bring out the competitive side in just about everyone and a few solid laughs.
The key to a perfect White Elephant game is of course, the gifts. Usually, the organizer will establish a reasonable price point, but you'll still want to find something unique and desirable within that range. Try thinking of it as a stocking stuffer—one that everyone will (playfully!) fight over. It might seem tricky to pick something that will please anybody at your gathering, but luckily we've included a variety of useful ideas below, from an $8 bath bomb to an adorable mini heart-shaped pillow. You’ll also find exfoliating foot masks, a toilet night light, a terrarium kit, various unique gifts for family, and more.
Ahead, shop the best White Elephant gifts that will make you the talk of the holiday festivities. And, some of these selects are discounted right now, so be sure to purchase before they’re back to full price!
Hearst Owned - 2/48
1) Toilet Night Light
Best 007
amazon.com
$8.99
OK, before you scroll past this, hear us out: We have personally received this very strange toilet night light at a White Elephant party before it was abruptly stolen (and then stolen again) making it the clear winner of the night. It definitely beats turning on the bathroom light at 3 a.m.
Amazon - 3/48
2) Shower Steamers
VieBeauti
amazon.com
$11.99
For the uninitiated: Steamers are like bath bombs for the shower. Just drop one on the floor, allow your shower to create some steam, and wait for your bathroom to be filled with relaxing, soothing scents. This set comes with six different options, including lavender, eucalyptus, and rose.
Amazon - 4/48
3) Touchscreen Driving Gloves
Trendoux
amazon.com
$9.99
Is there anything better than a simple pair of gloves that make navigating your cell phone on freezing cold days a little easier? We think not. This style comes in a variety of colors and also features non-slip silicone on the hand pads.
amazon.com - 5/48
4) Vanilla & Amber Soy Candle
DorothyBCo
etsy.com
$21.00
This hand-poured candle will be the talk of the party thanks to its delicious scent and colorful design. Undertones of sandalwood are the icing atop this sweet-smelling candle.
DorothyBCo - 6/48
5) Coinshot Mini Tabletop Cornhole Game Set
GoSports
amazon.com
$11.71
Just like the all-time classic lawn game, this mini cornhole set comes with everything you’ll need: two mini boards and 16 coins for two to four players. It’s also a whole lot easier to clean up and store the normal-size version.
Amazon - 7/48
6) Agate Coasters
Anthropologie
anthropologie.com
$16.00
While we love a good customizable gift, these one-of-a-kind coasters are pretty sweet too. Because they’re made from agate gemstones, each coaster is completely unique. Bonus: They still look unified even if you mix and match the colors. Anyone would be happy to snag this gift.
Anthropologie - 8/48
7) Avocado Hugger (Set of 2)
Food Huggers
amazon.com
$13.99
Let’s face it: Almost everyone loves avocados. Brown halves on the other hand? Not so much, which is why these avocado-shaped silicone covers make a universally great gift. It seals itself over the cut half, stopping air from getting in and preventing unsightly-gross browning.
Amazon - 9/48
8) Mini Terrariums DIY Kit
uncommongoods.com
$20.00
The terrarium trend will never go away and thankfully these little faux planties are in that camp. These succulents are actually made of felt, but look like the real thing. Plant Mom? Like it’s hard?
Uncommon Goods - 10/48
9) Exfoliating Foot Mask
Weida
amazon.com
$9.99
These slip-on, single-use mask booties contain ingredients that will help dry skin and calluses peel away. Is it gross? Absolutely. Is it totally amazing? More than you even know.
Amazon - 11/48
10) Sweetened Loose Leaf Sampler
Tea Drops
amazon.com
$15.99
Whoever keeps this sweet gift will embark on an unforgettable tasting journey. And you might not have heard of these unique flavors before, like rose earl grey and blueberry açai. Chances are they’ll be new to the recipient too!
Amazon - 12/48
11) Anti-Spill Cup Holder
HIT PRODUCTS
amazon.com
$25.00
Morning coffee and tea drinkers (a.k.a. everyone) will jump at this cup holder. The silicone holder keeps hot or cold drinks nearby and since it goes right over the armrest, the struggle between you and the side table can finally end.
Amazon - 13/48
12) Color Me Melanin: An Affirmation Coloring Book Featuring a Collection of Stress-Relieving Designs
Brooke T Rankins
amazon.com
$10.99
Unwind and destress with this coloring book. At just $11 it features 22 stress-relieving designs and affirmations sure to make them smile.
Color Me Melanin - 14/48
13) Mini Waffle Maker Machine for Individuals
DASH
amazon.com
$21.00
Breakfast is the most important meal of the day and this mini waffle maker will make cooking early morning meals quick and easy. Best part? Your waffles will come out heart-shaped, thanks to its cute design.
Amazon - 15/48
14) Cocktail Tumbler
BrüMate
amazon.com
22.99
Give the gift of a perfectly chilled cocktail with an insulated tumbler that prevents a top-tier party foul a.k.a. watered down mojitos or martinis. Perfect for outdoor night caps, this durable stainless-steel pick won’t shatter like traditional glassware would and you won’t spot an ounce of condensation, even in the warmest conditions.
Amazon - 16/48
15) Classics Gift Set
Burt’s Bees
amazon.com
$25.00
Give the gift of silky, smooth skin and hydrated lips with a collection of all-natural skincare products—all wonderfully curated in this totally gift-able (and steal-able) set.
Amazon - 17/48
16) Rechargeable LED Headlamp
Lighting EVER
amazon.com
$19.99
This headlamp is a White Elephant gift that will be put to good use. The rechargeable design features bright LED lights, is virtually weather-proof, and features different settings for use under various lighting conditions.
Amazon - 18/48
17) Tropical Glam Cat iPhone Case
Society6
society6.com
$21.00
All the cool cats will be vying for this fun gift. With models available from iPhone 6 through 14, there’s sure to be one that fits. afew folks’ phones. It’s also available in a slim or tough case, so you can choose the level of protection.
theebouffants - 19/48
18) Wine Lives Kitty Drink Markers
Genuine Fred
amazon.com
$11.59
Bringing wine glasses to a White Elephant party has been done, so instead we suggest wrapping up these funny drink markers that come with six napping “kitties” to help everyone easily locate their drink...without looking for their own lipstick stains on the rim. Don't look now, but your hosting friend is about ready to make the steal.
Amazon - 20/48
19) Cards Against Humanity
Cards Against Humanity LLC.
amazon.com
$29.00
“A party game for horrible people”—that’s the slogan for this iconic game night creation. While the jokes aren’t exactly savory and sometimes downright disgusting, it’s pretty much guaranteed to be a hit, especially after a couple glasses of wine. (Looking for a more PG version? Try Kids Against Maturity.)
Amazon - 21/48
20) Apéritif: Cocktail Hour the French Way: A Recipe Book
Rebekah Peppler
amazon.com
$13.79
From personal experience, this delightful little cocktail book is one that will actually be put to use. Author Rebekah Peppler pulled together a variety of beautiful, delicious, straightforward recipes combined with fab photography that might just inspire your host to shake up the drinks menu. Cheers!
Rebekah Peppler - 22/48
21) Reusable Rose Gold Metal Straws
Hiware
amazon.com
$9.99
Sustainable straws, but make them chic. The person who winds up with these will soon be obsessed—plus, you’re doing the planet a solid.
Amazon - 23/48
22) Ultrasonic Jewelry Cleaner
KRX
amazon.com
$64.97
Diamonds may be a girl’s best friend, but this jewelry cleaner just may be a close second. Featuring a powerful ultrasonic wave vibration of 47,000Hz, this tool works to cleanse and remove hard-to-reach stains from your valuables without damaging them. You can also use it to clean eyeglasses, watches, and more!
Amazon - 24/48
23) Wishing You Wellness Skincare Gift Set
Sephora
sephora.com
$40.00
Looking for the perfect beauty gift? Well, look no further than this 6-piece skincare gift set from Sephora complete with everything a beauty enthusiast might need for a a perfect complexion including a gua sha tool, face roller, ice globes, and more.
Sephora - 25/48
24) Hidden Pocket Scrunchies
Uncommon Goods
uncommongoods.com
$20.00
These are more than just your average scrunchies—they contain a hidden pocket to hold small essentials like cash and keys. The soft, velvet fabric is also kind to skin and hair.
Uncommon Goods - 26/48
25) Wooden Foot Massager
TheraFlow
amazon.com
$7.95
This nifty little gadget is perfect for those who are on their feet all day or who suffer from plantar fasciitis. It's small, portable, effective, and can be used almost anywhere.
TheraFlow - 27/48
26) Slipper Socks
EBMORE
amazon.com
$10.99
Cold weather also brings cold feet. These fuzzy socks are not only super warm and comfortable, but they’re also stylish and double as house slippers with a non-slip grip on the soles. Did we mention they’re super cozy too?
EBMORE - 28/48
27) Music Playing Cards
uncommongoods
uncommongoods.com
$10.00
Featuring loving illustrations of musical greats on each card, this deck splits up music genres into four suits including pop, rock, country, and R&B. Best part? Beyonce and Prince are the royalty of course...the Queen and Jack of Hearts.
Uncommon goods - 29/48
28) Self Care Tea Box
Sips by
sipsby.com
$15.00
This box includes teas for grounding, energizing, heart-healing, and sleep, plus exclusive illustrated self-care cards to align with each theme. It also includes exclusive discounts for each tea brand.
Sips by - 30/48
29) Mini Nail Polish Set
Nicole Miller New York
amazon.com
$19.99
This 15-piece set comes with a mix of metallic and trendy color polishes, including a pale mint we’re simply wild about. Steal-ability quotient: very strong.
Amazon - 31/48
30) AirPods Case Cover With Keychain
R-fun
amazon.com
$10.99
This silicone case slips on easily to protect the AirPods case from scratches, bumps, and drops. It also comes with a detachable carabiner clip, making it convenient to attach it to a handbag or backpack.
Amazon - 32/48
31) Candle Wick Trimmer & Accessory
calary
amazon.com
$16.85
Perfect for all candle lovers, this top-notch gift set comes with a wick trimmer, candle snuffer, and dipper. It’s made from stainless steel, so the material won’t rust or bend, overtime. The gold coating is also so elegant-looking that you won’t even want to wrap it.
Amazon - 33/48
32) Sweet Hot Recipe
Capital City Mambo Sauce
amazon.com
$16.99
Everyone will vie for these delicious wing sauces. It’ll elevate everything from chicken wings to a burger, and it tastes oh so good. And with a price point of under $20, what’s not to love?
Capital City Mambo Sauce - 34/48
33) It’s All Good Sticky Note Packet
Knock Knock
amazon.com
$9.43
We all need a few sticky notes now and then, so might as well make them fun! This pick has the best personality, so even when your friend is jotting down something as trivial as a grocery list, they’ll still feel super accomplished.
Amazon - 35/48
34) 4 Cheese Knives Set-Mini Knife, Butter Knife & Fork
YXChome
amazon.com
$9.89
Even if it’s just a block of cheddar, fancy cheese knives have a way of elevating any experience surrounding a charcuterie board—and that will be particularly true the next time your host pulls out this set.
Amazon - 37/48
36) Double 6 Professional Domino Tiles
CHH
amazon.com
$13.79
Gifting a game during a holiday gifting game? How meta—and also brilliant. Plus, this retro looking set is both aesthetically pleasing and more fun to play than you remember.
amazon.com - 38/48
37) CrystalBliss Aromatherapy Candle
EmanateEssentials
etsy.com
$22.00
These aromatherapy candles contain hand-selected crystals that promote healing, self-love, and peace. Once the crystals are revealed, you can tuck it into a pocket or place it around the home as inspirational decor.
Etsy - 39/48
38) World of Flowers: A Coloring Book and Floral Adventure
Penguin Books
amazon.com
$10.40
Pair this adult coloring book with a set of markers and you’re set with a soothing gift that can also be easily re-gifted to someone else. (Did we mention that’s another great part of White Elephant exchanges? Even if you don’t get what you want, you might be able to pass along the perfect thing for someone else!)
Amazon - 40/48
39) Whole Bean Coffee
Real Good Coffee Company
amazon.com
$29.99
Tonight the bubbles are flowing. Tomorrow everyone is going to need a strong cup of coffee. This delicious breakfast blend from a beloved Seattle roasting company should do the trick—and the beans will last well into the New Year.
amazon.com - 41/48
40) Reusable Shopping Bag
BAGGU
amazon.com
$12.00
This cult-favorite reusable bag is highly collectible and 100% adorable. No matter how many bags they already have, we guarantee they’ll want another. Each Baggu bag is made of durable nylon and can withstand up to 50 pounds.
Amazon - 42/48
41) "Drinks Are on Me!" Coasters
MCPressure
etsy.com
$18.50
We love all the designs from this cheeky shop but this “drinks are on me” one is a pun any host will appreciate. Bonus: They’re totally reusable.
etsy.com - 43/48
42) Cream Heart Shaped Throw Pillow
DEMDACO
amazon.com
$38.54
The most caring gift you can give is a hug and this pillow will allow you to do just that. It features a super soft knitted yarn and feels lightweight, making it the perfect addition to any couch or bed. We also can’t get over how cute the heart shape is!
Amazon - 44/48
43) Microwave Pasta Cooker- The Original Fasta Pasta
Fasta Pasta
amazon.com
$17.99
Who doesn’t love pasta? This trendy gadget allows you to enjoy your favorite food without the wait. Best of all, it’s easy to use (just pop it in the microwave), clean, and yields tasty meals.
Fasta Pasta - 45/48
44) Movie Night Popcorn Variety Pack
Urban Accents
amazon.com
$29.99
This gift box will have everyone looking forward to hosting their next movie night. With five different varieties of seasoned popcorn including white cheddar, sweet and salty kettle corn, chili lime, buttery caramel, and sizzling sriracha, there’s sure to be something for everyone to love.
Urban Accents - 46/48
45) Velvet Cleansing Milk
Stratia
stratiaskin.com
$27.00
Harsh foaming cleansers can strip the skin of essential oils, so it’s best to use ones formulated to create a creamy lather like this cleansing milk. It uses a water-soluble form of olive oil to gently bond to dirt and buildup on the face.
Stratia - 47/48
46) Perfect Form Lip Balm SPF 15
EleVen by Venus Williams
credobeauty.com
$19.00
Keep everyone’s lips soft, silky, and protected during the cold weather with this Perfect Form Lip Balm. Formulated with shea butter and SPF 15, it’s the first-of-its-kind lip sunscreen that’s a must-have for everyone.
credo - 48/48
47) “Golden Girls” Sophia Face Mini Ceramic Planter
Silver Buffalo
amazon.com
$19.99
Warning: This garden club-approved gift comes with the sudden urge to erupt into the Golden Girls theme song whenever you see it. Perfect for those with green thumbs and TV fans alike, this mini succulent planter features the face of Sophia and makes a great conversation piece. Thank you for being a friend indeed.
Silver Buffalo
