"We didn’t speak the whole night and then he left early to go to another party and I thought, ‘Okay that went well,' " the actress recalled
"Is it true that when you met your husband, you were being set up on a blind date and you actually thought that maybe he and your sister would make a good match?" asked Drew Barrymore.
"I did — well, only because he wasn’t speaking to me [on the date]. And somehow, I did a bad thing," said Pfeiffer.
According to the Batman Returns star, the date was supposed to be a one-on-one outing, "but I decided it should be a group date. I still don't know why it was a bad idea."
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human-interest stories.
Pfeiffer said she "was anxious," and that the date "didn't go well." As she explained, "We were in this restaurant and there were eight of us, and somehow [David] ended up sitting across from my sister and I ended up sitting across from his best friend."
"We didn’t speak the whole night, and then he left early to go to another party and I thought, ‘Okay that went well,' " Pfeiffer recalled.
But it all worked out in the end. "He actually finally called me two days later — that was also not okay. He called and we ended up talking on the phone for an hour, and it just went [from] that," she said.
At the time of their meeting, Pfeiffer was already in the process of adopting her daughter, Claudia. She and Kelley, a longtime TV creator and producer, had only been dating for about two months when she brought Claudia home.
"So we had this child with us right away, and most people don't have that. But I really got to see [David] in a situation that certainly would separate the boys from the men. Obviously, he really rose to the occasion," Pfeiffer told Good Housekeeping in 2007. "We both got to see each other as parents before we progressed in our relationship together and, in a strange way, it took the pressure off, as a couple."
She continued, "It was sort of perfectly timed. I mean, it's a real testament to the kind of person he is, but also to the fact that sometimes the traditional way of doing things isn't always the best way."
The couple tied the knot in November 1993, and Kelley officially adopted Claudia that same year. The following year, they welcomed their son, John Henry.
For more People news, make sure to sign up for our newsletter!
Read the original article on People.