'The most amazing shoe I've ever worn': This 'comfortable yet stylish' shoe is Everlane's best-seller

Kate Mendonca
Shopping Editor
Image via Everlane.

Every once in a while a product comes along that’s so good you can’t help but rave about it to anyone and everyone who’ll listen. One such item is the cult-favourite women’s Day Glove by Everlane, which customers are calling “the most amazing shoe [they’ve] ever worn.”

With more than 4,000 reviews (and counting) and an 4.6 star average rating, these slip-ons are no ordinary ballet flats. According to the Everlane website, “the Day Glove is made of buttery soft leather that molds to your foot for a perfect, custom fit.” They shoes, which are the brand’s no. 1 best-seller, are available in 16 colours, and come in women’s sizes 5-11, meaning every woman can find the flats of her dreams.

Shoppers are loving the comfort and everyday wearability of their Day Gloves, with one happy customer writing, “These shoes are so comfortable yet stylish. I can walk/stand in them all day, and they are really easy to dress up or dress down. I have two pairs of the Day Glove and I'm hopeful to order a third pair in mauve once they are restocked!”

Though they are meant to be a snug fit, customers with wide feet have noted that sizing up a half size gave them the best fit and extra room. “This flat does narrow so I suggest sizing up a half size or full size depending on your foot width,” writes one reviewer. “My feet aren’t super narrow and I still love these shoes.”

Image via Everlane.

The Day Glove retails for $150 CAD ($115 USD) and are made from 100 per cent Italian leather, which typically sells for $240 in a traditional retail environment. Thanks to Everlane’s modified profit margins and direct-to-consumer business model, they’re able to keep prices low and quality high.

Check out the best-selling Everlane Day Glove below, as well as five editor-approved ballet flats that will keep your feet happy all day long.

Everlane The Day Glove

Image via Everlane.

SHOP IT: Everlane, $150 ($115 USD)

Everlane The Day Glove ReKnit

Image via Everlane.

SHOP IT: Everlane, $128 ($98 USD)

Chloé Lauren Scalloped Ballet Flat

Image via Nordstrom.

SHOP IT: Nordstrom, $495

H&M Ballet Flats

Image via H&M.

SHOP IT: H&M, $15

Charlotte Olympia Black Velvet Kitty Flats

Image via SSENSE.

SHOP IT: SSENSE, $257 (originally $525)

Call It Spring Vie Loafers

Image via Call It Spring.

SHOP IT: Call It Spring, $50

The editors at Yahoo Lifestyle Canada are committed to finding you the best products at the best prices. At times, we may receive a share from purchases made via links on this page.

Let us know what you think by commenting below and tweeting @YahooStyleCA! Follow us on Twitter and Instagram.