WordPress.org bans WP Engine, blocks it from accessing its resources

Ivan Mehta
Updated ·4 min read

WordPress drama went up another notch on Wednesday after WordPress.org, the open source web-hosting software, banned hosting provider WP Engine from accessing its resources.

In a post on WordPress.org, WordPress co-creator and Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg wrote that pending their legal claims, WP Engine will not have access to the platform's resources, such as themes and plug-ins.

"WP Engine wants to control your WordPress experience, they need to run their own user login system, update servers, plugin directory, theme directory, pattern directory, block directory, translations, photo directory, job board, meetups, conferences, bug tracker, forums, Slack, Ping-o-matic, and showcase. Their servers can no longer access our servers for free," he said.

"WP Engine is free to offer their hacked up, bastardized simulacra of WordPress’s GPL code to their customers, and they can experience WordPress as WP Engine envisions it, with them getting all of the profits and providing all of the services," Mullenweg wrote.

As a result of this block, sites using WP Engine's solutions cannot install plug-ins or update their themes.

https://twitter.com/ViewFromTheBox/status/1839046583272485352 https://twitter.com/bgardner/status/1839070322617643212 https://twitter.com/mgeheren/status/1839067797080379552

As several WordPress developers and advocates pointed out, the ban also prevents WP Engine customers from accessing security updates, leaving them vulnerable.

WP Engine acknowledged this issue and said the company is working on a fix.

"WordPress.org has blocked WP Engine customers from updating and installing plugins and themes via WP Admin. There is currently no impact on the performance, reliability, or security of your site, nor does it impact your ability to make updates to your code or content," an update from WP Engine read.

In response to the incident, WP Engine said in a post that Mullenweg had misused his control of WordPress to interfere with WP Engine customers' access to WordPress.org.

"Matt Mullenweg’s unprecedented and unwarranted action interferes with the normal operation of the entire WordPress ecosystem, impacting not just WP Engine and our customers, but all WordPress plugin developers and open-source users who depend on WP Engine tools like ACF," WP Engine said.

https://twitter.com/wpengine/status/1839246341660119287

The WP Engine vs. Automattic fight

It's important to understand that WordPress powers nearly 40% of the websites on the internet through different hosting providers, which include Mullenweg's Automattic and WP Engine. Users can also take the open source project and run the websites themselves, but a lot of people choose to go with plug-and-play solutions.

The fight began last week when Mullenweg criticized WP Engine publicly at a conference and on his blog for profiteering and called it a "cancer to WordPress." He also alleged the company doesn't contribute as much as Automattic does to the WordPress community despite both of them making about a half-billion dollars in revenue annually.

This spurred WP Engine to send a cease-and-desist letter to Mullenweg and Automattic, asking them to withdraw their comments. The letter alleged that Mullenweg and Automattic had threatened to adopt a "scorched earth nuclear approach" if WP Engine did not comply and pay Automattic a percentage of its gross revenue.

In reply, Automattic sent its own cease-and-desist letter to WP Engine, alleging infringement of the WordPress and WooCommerce trademarks.

Separately, the WordPress Foundation, a charity created by Mullenweg to maintain WordPress as an open source project, told TechCrunch that WP Engine has violated its trademarks.

"WP Engine has indeed breached the WordPress Trademark Policy. The Policy states that no one is allowed to use the WordPress trademarks as part of a product, project, service, domain name, or company name. WP Engine has repeatedly violated this policy and the Cease and Desist letter sent to them by Automattic provides examples of some of the many violations," the foundation said in an email.

The policy was updated yesterday to include an example of WP Engine. Notably, the policy doesn't cover "WP" as a trademark.

Hours after banning WP Engine from WordPress.org, Mullenweg wrote on his blog that trademarks are the core issue. He said Automattic has been trying to sign a licensing deal with WP Engine for a long time. He noted that the company offered WP Engine the option to either pay a direct licensing fee or make in-kind contributions to the open source project. However, he didn't clarify what making in-kind contributions would mean.

You can contact this reporter at im@ivanmehta.com or on Signal: @ivan.42

Latest Stories

  • The WordPress vs. WP Engine drama, explained

    The world of WordPress, one of the most popular technologies for creating and hosting websites, is going through a very heated controversy. The core issue is the fight between WordPress founder and Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg and WP Engine, which hosts websites built on WordPress. WordPress technology is open source and free, and it powers a huge chunk of the internet — around 40% of websites.

  • Analyst Says Initial Wait Times for Apple (AAPL) iPhone 16 are ‘Uninspiring’

    We recently published a list of 10 Buzzing AI Stocks on Latest News and Analyst Ratings. Since Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL) ranks 2nd on the list, it deserves a deeper look. Investors are still digesting the Fed’s aggressive rate cut and charting the path forward. Roger Altman, Evercore founder and senior chairman, said while talking to CNBC in […]

  • Google’s $2.7 Billion Move to Re-Hire AI Genius Draws Attention

    Google’s $2.7 billion dollar deal with AI leader Noam Shazeer is the latest and most eye watering check cut in a string of lucrative hiring transactions by tech leaders scrambling to woo prized artificial intelligence talent.Shazeer, the co-author of a key research paper that sparked the artificial intelligence boom, first joined Google in 2000 as one of the company’s first few hundred employees, but left in 2021 to start his own company after the tech giant refused to debut a chatbot he created

  • Wall Street fears lower-than-anticipated iPhone demand as shipping times shrink

    Wall Street is raising concerns about the latest iPhone's shorter shipping times.

  • Newsmax Settles Defamation Case With 2020 Election Firm on Eve of Trial

    Newsmax settled a major 2020 presidential election defamation lawsuit with Smartmatic hours after jury selection for the civil trial began on Thursday. The terms of the last-minute agreement remain unknown. “Newsmax is pleased to announce it has resolved the litigation brought by Smartmatic through a confidential settlement,” the cable network said in a statement. The conservative news company, however, faces a separate election-related defamation lawsuit filed by Dominion Voting Systems, in whi

  • Huawei heats up global smartwatch market with new GT 5 series to challenge Apple Watch

    Huawei Technologies is stepping up its competition with Apple beyond 5G smartphones, with the launch of its latest smartwatch series in China and Europe nearly a decade after the Shenzhen-based firm introduced its first device in that category. At an event in Shanghai on Tuesday, Huawei introduced on the mainland its new Watch GT 5 series - with prices starting at 1,488 yuan (US$212) - featuring a slimmer design, upgraded antenna and algorithm for improved positioning accuracy, up to two weeks o

  • Naomi Campbell reacts after being banned as charity trustee

    Naomi Campbell reacts after being banned as charity trustee

  • Tropical Storm Helene: What travellers should know before travelling south

    Travel expert Claire Newell shares vital tips as Florida braces for Tropical Storm Helene. We also cover WestJet's $2,000 compensation ruling, a new Vancouver Airport tech upgrade allowing liquids in carry-ons, and a couple's ban from Cathay Pacific over a seat-reclining spat. Plus, find out how travel could help slow aging!

  • Okanagan woman sues former doctor who sexually assaulted her

    A B.C. woman is suing her former doctor and the staff of his Vernon, B.C., medical clinic after the former physician was convicted of sexually assaulting her and two other women connected to his clinic. In July, Peter Inkpen was sentenced to three-and-a-half years in prison on three counts of sexual assault. Inkpen is in court facing one additional count of sexual assault.The identities of the victims and the alleged victim in the ongoing trial are protected by a court-ordered publication ban. H

  • PayPal courts cross-border merchants in Shenzhen with expanded services in China

    US digital payments platform PayPal is stepping up efforts to support Chinese cross-border merchants with the launch of new services in Shenzhen, tapping into booming exports from the country despite economic headwinds. PayPal's China business recorded double-digit growth in the past year, Hannah Qiu, senior vice-president and China CEO of PayPal, said at a company event in the country's southern tech hub on Thursday. "This is impressive growth considering the pressure and challenges facing the

  • These Bitcoin Miners Are Gearing Up to Cash in on Potential AI Windfall

    More and more crypto mining companies are diversifying into AI. This transition could create great buying opportunities in publically listed Bitcoin mining stocks. In this article, we'll take a look at stocks that may be posed to benefit the most from this pivot. Looking for actionable trade ideas to navigate the current market volatility? Unlock access to InvestingPro’s AI-selected stock winners for under $9 a month! The crypto-currency mining sector is undergoing a major transformation, with B

  • China's EV makers pull out all the stops to beat Tesla in autonomous driving race

    A battle for supremacy in autonomous driving is escalating in mainland China, as major electric vehicle (EV) makers speed up development of cars with advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) to lure buyers. Their effort to build intelligent cars in the world's largest automotive market represents a threat to Tesla's position as a global leader in self-driving, analysts said. "Preliminary autonomous driving systems have emerged as a new battlefront for electric car builders in China because they

  • Micron shares surge after upbeat first-quarter forecast due to AI demand for memory chips

    (Reuters) -Micron Technology shares surged roughly 14% in after-hours trading after the memory maker forecast higher than expected first-quarter revenue due to the thirst for its memory chips used in artificial intelligence computing. Micron is one of the only three providers of high-bandwidth memory (HBM) chips along with South Korea's SK Hynix and Samsung, which has allowed the U.S. firm to cash in on demand for semiconductors that help power generative AI technology. HBM is a space-saving, power-efficient type of dynamic random access memory chip, or DRAM, crucial for AI-focused graphics processing units, that aid in processing vast amounts of data.

  • EV sales in Europe hit a speed bump — and the US should be worried too

    Registrations of new EVs in Europe fell by 44% in August from the previous year, according to the European Automobile Manufacturers' Association.

  • China's top chip equipment maker sees two US executives step aside amid tech war tensions

    Two executives with US citizenship at Chinese chip gear maker Advanced Micro-Fabrication Equipment (AMEC) have stepped down from their positions, as trade tensions between the US and China continue to escalate. Ni Tuqiang and Yang Wei, both US citizens, are no longer "core technical personnel" at AMEC, which is widely seen as China's best hope to produce advanced etching and deposition tools to cut reliance on foreign suppliers, for "personal reasons", but the two remain employees of the company

  • Diners are skipping restaurants and making more meals at home as inflation trend inverts

    NEW YORK (AP) — Eating in is in and eating out is out.

  • Exclusive-Canadian payments software firm Lightspeed explores sale, sources say

    SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) -Lightspeed Commerce, a Canadian payments software maker with a market value of C$3.2 billion ($2.37 billion), is working with a financial adviser to explore options including a potential sale, according to people familiar with the matter. The sale talks come months after the Montreal-based company replaced its CEO Jean Paul Chauvet and brought back founder Dax Dasilva at the helm, as investors raised concerns over the company's plan to prioritize growth over profitability following disappointing quarterly results in February. Lightspeed has tapped investment bankers at JPMorgan Chase to evaluate its options and solicit interest from potential buyers, which could include private equity firms, the sources said, requesting anonymity as the discussions are confidential.

  • Net Worth for Retirees: How To Tell Whether You’re Poor, Middle Class or Rich

    In retirement, net worth shows the total result of a lifetime's savings, debts and investments. This measure is often more insightful than income, as it reveals your financial stability and whether...

  • Huawei’s Newest Smartphone Folds Into Thirds

    The Mate XT Ultimate Design can be used in single, dual, or triple-screen mode.

  • Voting technology firm, conservative outlet reach settlement in 2020 election defamation case

    A settlement was reached Thursday in a defamation lawsuit brought by electronic voting machine manufacturer Smartmatic against conservative news outlet Newsmax for airing accusations about vote manipulation in the 2020 election made by allies of former President Donald Trump. The settlement was announced just a few hours after jury selection began in the lawsuit filed by Florida-based Smartmatic against Newsmax. Smartmatic claimed that Newsmax program hosts and guests made false and defamatory statements in November and December 2020 implying that Smartmatic participated in rigging the results and that its software was used to switch votes.