I’m A Former Baker, And I Tested Two Popular Grocery Store Croissants To Find Out Which One Is Better (And The Results Truly Shocked Me)

There are few cravings more inconvenient than a warm, fresh, flaky croissant on a random weekday morning. And I don’t mean a sad, day-old coffee shop croissant; I’m talking about the real thing, baby. Shatteringly crisp on the outside, with that classic honeycomb crumb throughout, ready to be slathered in jam or hazelnut spread.

Unfortunately, that level of croissant excellence isn’t always easy to come by. So when I spotted frozen croissants at both Trader Joe’s and Whole Foods, I decided to put them to the test and crown a winner. And yes, I speak with authority here as a former professional baker and a former pregnant person with a very serious croissant craving.

Related: 28 Deliciously Warm Recipes To Make In February When Winter Feels Like It's Never Going To End

I have worked in bakeries and made croissants myself, so I’ll be the first to admit they are a true labor of love. Between laminating, folding, chilling, proofing, and praying to the butter gods, croissants are not exactly simple. Which is exactly why the potential of frozen croissants were so appealing; they could have all the payoff with none of the 48-hour commitment.

The Whole Foods croissants came out to $7.99 for 12 minis, while the Trader Joe's ones were $5.99 for 8 minis. In addition to the mini croissants, both grocers sell full-size chocolate take-and-bake croissants, and Whole Foods also stocks full-size regular croissants.

Taste-Test: Whole Foods Frozen Croissants

From frozen, the Whole Foods version immediately looked like a ringer — visibly handmade, beautifully shaped, and with instructions that included a short room temperature proof before baking (a detail I appreciated). I was fully prepared to crown them the obvious winner from looks alone.

But then I baked them. I followed the directions to a tee, and the disappointment started the moment I opened the oven. Instead of puffing into tall and deeply golden pastries, they looked more bready than flaky. They were rounded and soft, without the dramatic exterior I look for in a great croissant. From the outside, I could still spot hints of lamination, which gave me a sliver of hope, so I held out hope that the interior might surprise me — because sometimes the magic really does happen on the inside.

Related: If You Can Score 10/12 Or Higher On This Salad Trivia Quiz, You're A Certified Veggie Expert

When sliced open, the interior lacked that dramatic honeycomb structure. The layers were present, but compressed, resulting in a slightly gummy texture in the center rather than the light, airy pull you expect from a properly laminated croissant. Flavor-wise, it was...fine, but definitely didn't knock my socks off. It’s absolutely serviceable, especially when warmed and paired with coffee, but it reads more like a decent grocery-store croissant than something that could pass for bakery-made. Solid, yes, but not the one I’d reach for when the craving really hits.

Taste-Test: Trader Joe's Frozen Croissants

Related: Based On The Appetizers You Choose, I Know Your EXACT Birth Date

And just when I was feeling defeated and absolutely sure that a 10 out of 10 frozen croissant couldn't be done, Trader Joe’s entered the chat and changed the game.

TJ’s frozen croissants baked up very well. They appeared to be golden, flaky, and well-layered, with an impressive height and obvious crispiness. They didn't have much butter seepage, and I was truly shocked at the quality!

But I knew the real test would come once they were cut in half. Would they reveal that elusive, classic honeycomb interior, the hallmark of a truly great French croissant? Spoiler: Trader Joe’s delivered.

The interior opened up to a bakery-worthy honeycomb that actually made me gasp. Delicate, irregular pockets, layered and airy, with structure but no doughiness in sight. I honestly didn’t think this was possible from a frozen croissant. Hopes officially raised, I took a bite, and they followed through. The flavor was exactly what you want from a traditional French croissant: rich, buttery, and deeply satisfying without tipping into greasy or heavy. The salt level was balanced, with just a hint of sweetness and no greasiness.

Related: If You Can Name These 15 Iconic Candy Bar Logos, Your Visual Memory Is Exceptional

Texturally, it hit all the right notes: crisp on the exterior with a tender, slightly chewy interior that pulled apart in wispy layers. There was no gumminess, no dense center — just that classic contrast between crackly crust and soft, laminated crumb. It tasted like something that had been proofed properly, baked hot, and pulled from the oven at exactly the right moment. If you’d told me this came from a freezer aisle, I wouldn’t have believed you!

My conclusion? This little secret hack is officially going in my back pocket for future brunches when I need to impress with minimal effort. Don’t sleep on the Trader Joe’s frozen croissants — flaky, buttery, and shockingly good. I’ve tested them, I’ve compared them, and I’ve officially crowned a winner.

Feeling adventurous enough to try making croissants at home? Download the free Tasty app to access our tried-and-tested best croissant recipe — no subscription required.

Also in Tasty: If You Can Name 13/15 Of These Unwrapped Candy Bars, You’re Officially A Snack Master

Also in Tasty: This 15-Question Egg Quiz Is So Hard, You Won't Be Able To Ace It Unless You Go For Brunch Regularly

Also in Tasty: I'm Sorry, I Am, But I REALLY Don't Think Anyone's Passing This Difficult Desserts Logo Quiz

Read it on BuzzFeed.com