Woman claims she was denied job position for not ‘putting enough effort into her appearance’

Brittany Miller
·3 min read

There can be a myriad of reasons why an employer may decide not to hire you, and one woman is convinced it’s because she wasn’t wearing makeup during her job interview.

Melissa Weaver recently made a TikTok to see what people’s opinions were on wearing makeup to both a job interview and the workplace in general, while also telling the story of what happened when she was denied a vice-president job herself.

“So I interviewed for a job earlier this week,” her video began. “The interview went so well, every question she had, I had a great answer for. I used to work in recruitment, I know how to interview. My background and experience aligns perfectly with what the role entails.”

Weaver then explained that she received a rejection email from the recruiter for the position and decided to ask for feedback, which she “rarely” does.

“She said that while my background was exactly what they were looking for, my experience lined up with what they needed for the position, and my own personal goals and values aligned with the company’s; she was concerned that for my interview, I hadn’t put in enough effort in my appearance, given the level of role I was interviewing for,” she said in her TikTok.

The job seeker explained what she was wearing for the interview which included a blazer, fresh blow-out for her hair, and earrings, but no makeup. “I didn’t have on any makeup because I don’t really wear a lot of makeup,” she explained.

She then wondered out loud if not wearing makeup actually conveyed to people that you are unprofessional or not putting in as much effort to your job.

Her video went on to receive over 700,000 views with many people leaving comments questioning if that could be grounds for a gender-discrimination lawsuit.

“That honestly feels like discrimination. Not hiring you based on your looks?” one comment read.

Another agreed, writing, “It’s wild she said that in an email to you... this would never be said to a man.”

“Not reasonable. Do men get refused a job because they don’t wear makeup?” a third commenter questioned.

Weaver then made a follow-up video discussing what she was doing next, which mostly boiled down to her just moving on and continuing with her job search. She explained that she would refrain from outright naming the company she interviewed with for the sake of not jeopardising her continuing job search.

“I don’t want companies to come across my videos and think they shouldn’t interview me for a job because if they feel like I’m not a good fit, then I’m going to slander them,” she said.

Even if she did just forward the email to someone higher up in the company, she was worried about the recruiter telling recruiters at other companies about her, which would prevent her from getting a job.

In terms of filing a lawsuit, Weaver added that because she is still job hunting, this isn’t an action that she has the time or money for. And while companies in the United States cannot discriminate against who they hire based on gender, they can choose not to hire someone because of the way they present themselves.

“The recruiter interpreted that as, I wasn’t excited about the opportunity, I didn’t take the opportunity seriously, or that I took the role seriously. I think that’s very unfair and unfortunate because I was excited about it. That was just how she perceived it, and she’s allowed to, so I will not be suing them,” she said.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest Stories

  • These are 5 things you need to stop doing in your 50s and 60s in order to have a happier retirement — but can you do it?

    It's time for your second act.

  • Many older workers lose disability benefits after 65

    Canada’s workforce is older than it has ever been, and many are surprised to learn they could lose access to short- and long-term disability insurance the day they turn 65.

  • $9.5M sexual abuse class-action lawsuit against Stampede moves forward with 300 claimants

    About 300 people have joined a $9.5-million class action lawsuit against the Calgary Stampede, which admitted negligence after a serial sexual abuser worked for decades with teenage performers from the Young Canadians, a judge heard Tuesday. Lawyers for the claimants and Stampede were in court Tuesday to update Court of King's Bench Justice Paul Jeffrey on how the funds will be distributed and to work out details of a plan to notify all potential class members of an upcoming settlement approval

  • Trans Mountain pipeline expansion gets green light to open for May 1

    CALGARY — The long-awaited Trans Mountain pipeline expansion is complete and the Canada Energy Regulator has given the go-ahead for the project to open. The regulator said Tuesday it has approved the last remaining "leave to open" applications submitted by Trans Mountain Corp., the Crown corporation behind the project. Approval of these applications was required before the expanded pipeline could begin shipping oil. Also on Tuesday, Trans Mountain confirmed that Wednesday, May 1 will mark the co

  • Elon Musk lays off Tesla execs, plans more cuts

    STORY: Elon Musk looks to be doing more layoffs at Tesla. Reports by The Information on Tuesday (April 30) say he’s fired two top executives, and plans to get rid of hundreds more workers. Musk is said to be frustrated by falling sales, and the pace of earlier job cuts. The story quotes an email said to be from Musk. In it he says, “these actions are making it clear that we need to be absolutely hard core about headcount”. In an apparent warning to managers, he says “while some on exec staff are taking this seriously, most are not yet doing so”. There was no immediate response to a Reuters request for comment. It all follows a move earlier this month to shed some 10% of the company’s workforce. Tesla is grappling with falling sales and an intensifying price war which it started. Reporting earnings last week, it said all that led to its first quarterly drop in revenue since 2020. Musk this weekend made a surprise visit to China, the epicenter of the price battle. There he made progress on rolling out the brand’s advanced driver assistance features in the country. However, Tesla faces fierce competition from local makers like BYD in what is now the world’s biggest car market.

  • Assault charges against two Halifax Alehouse bouncers withdrawn before trial

    Assault charges against two security guards who worked at a downtown Halifax bar have been withdrawn moments before their trial was supposed to get underway.Alexander Levy, 38, and Matthew Day, 33, were both charged in relation to an incident outside the Halifax Alehouse on Oct. 10, 2022. A customer was allegedly attacked by two bouncers and held in a choke hold after being kicked out of the bar. A Crown lawyer told Judge Kelly Serbu in Halifax provincial court on Tuesday they will not be procee

  • Germany's struggle to clean up its supply chains has lessons for Europe

    German engineering company BAUCH makes machines and engine components out of materials mined in China, Africa or South America that pass through multiple hands and processes before they reach its factories in southern Germany and China. To comply with Germany's new Supply Chain Act, BAUCH, like other firms with more than 1,000 staff, must take due diligence procedures to monitor suppliers' human rights and environmental protection standards - a task which CEO Manfred Bauch says is almost impossible and threatens to rip apart his supply chain.

  • Michael Cohen is cashing in on the Trump trial with TikTok livestreams

    As he waits to testify in Donald Trump's hush money trial, Michael Cohen is discussing the proceedings on TikTok - which some experts say could hurt him in the courtroom.

  • Earn an Extra $100 Before Bed: 6 Quick Nightly Side Gigs

    Saving money or having the extra cash to spend as you wish can seem like a pipe dream in an era of economic uncertainty.

  • Never complain, but do explain: How to handle job tasks in the hiring process, whether Gen Z is involved or not

    There are zero issues with using tests as part of a hiring process, when used fairly. But nobody wants to feel like their time is being wasted.

  • Case dropped against ‘traumatised’ former senior officer Novlett Robyn Williams

    Novlett Robyn Williams was accused of failing repeatedly to comply with her sex offender notification requirements.

  • Fraudsters target small businesses with scams. Here are some to watch out for

    NEW YORK (AP) — It's never fun to be scammed, but if you're a small business owner then falling for a scam can have long-lasting effects on a business, damaging client relationships and profit. Plenty of types of scams exist, but a few affect small businesses the most. According to the Federal Trade Commission, small businesses should be on the lookout for phony invoices and unordered merchandise. Scammers send out fake invoices and hope businesses won't notice. Similarly, scammers call saying t

  • Starbucks Is Having Its Worst Day Since 2020. Expensive Coffee Finally Takes Toll.

    Net sales in the March quarter totaled $8.56 billion, while analysts polled by FactSet expected $9.13 billion.

  • Musk disbands Tesla EV charging team, leaving customers in the dark

    DETROIT (Reuters) -Elon Musk's abrupt decision to lay off employees who ran Tesla's electric vehicle charging business blindsided automakers gearing up to equip new EVs for customers to use the Tesla Supercharger network, industry officials and analysts said on Tuesday. For now, General Motors, Ford and other automakers which struck deals last year to give customers access to the network said they are not changing their plans. Tesla's decision to open its network to rival EV manufacturers was hailed by U.S. President Joe Biden, and opened the door for Tesla to get federal subsidies to expand the reach of its North American Charging Standard (NACS) system.

  • Huawei's high-profile consumer CEO Richard Yu shifts role

    While Yu becomes chairman, He Gang, the consumer business group's chief operating officer, will take over as the unit's CEO, the people said. Yu has headed Huawei's consumer unit, which includes its smartphone business, since 2012, a period marked by rapid growth, a hit from U.S. sanctions to the company's supply chain and more recently a rebound in sales. Yu's role as chairman of Huawei's smart car solutions business, a unit the company has said it intends to spin off into a new company, is unchanged, the person said.

  • Starbucks stock plunges 14% after badly missing its Q2 earnings estimates

    Starbucks' decaf-like start to the year continues into the second quarter.

  • Californians fed up with fast food chains hiking prices are now biting back — by taking their business elsewhere

    Fast food at fine dining prices?

  • Google and Apple now threatened by the US antitrust laws that helped build their technology empires

    SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — The U.S. Justice Department's double-barreled antitrust attack on Google's dominant search and Apple's trendsetting iPhone is reviving memories of the epic battle that hobbled Microsoft before it roared back to yet again become the world's most valuable company. The parallels to the Justice Department's landmark antitrust case in 1998 could provide a window into the potential breakthroughs that could be unleashed if regulators succeed in their attempts to crack down on Googl

  • Americans have tipping fatigue. Domino’s thinks it has the answer

    Americans are being asked to tip on digital screens for everything from a cup of coffee to self-checkout at grocery stores, and many are frustrated with the new tipping culture.

  • US fast-food chains may have to amp up promotions as more people eat at home

    Global fast food giants may have to dole out steeper promotions to lure inflation-hit customers who are increasingly opting to eat at home, following weak sales from the likes of McDonald's and Starbucks this week. Disposable income in the United States is declining, particularly in the lower-income cohort, while the slow economic recovery in China has increased industry-wide pressures for quick-service chains including KFC owner Yum Brands that has extended across several quarters. "The lack of value offers has opened up consumers to shop for different options whether it be other (chains) or the grocery stores," Razmig Poundardjian, portfolio manager for Carnegie Investment Counsel said.